Which Brachiosaurus (Giraffatitan) figure is better?

[Joey]

I'm having a pretty hard time deciding which figure is better -
The Invicta Brachiosaurus or the 2007 Carnegie Brachiosaurus green repaint?
I really want some pros and cons of each figure and really, an experts opinion of the figures.

[Lanthanotus]

I'm having a pretty hard time deciding which figure is better -
The Invicta Brachiosaurus or the 2007 Carnegie Brachiosaurus green repaint?
I really want some pros and cons of each figure and really, an experts opinion of the figures.

When you say green repaint you mean this one?

[Joey]

I'm having a pretty hard time deciding which figure is better -
The Invicta Brachiosaurus or the 2007 Carnegie Brachiosaurus green repaint?
I really want some pros and cons of each figure and really, an experts opinion of the figures.

When you say green repaint you mean this one?

Yes, I should of probably just said the 2007 version not 'repaint'.

[Lanthanotus]

Well, both are outdated but you sure are aware of that. If only to add one of these to my collection I'd personally go for the Invicta, just because I find it more elegant/majestic and not as goofy/funny looking in the face. The Invicta though has cheeks which makes it mouth look rather small. Also on the plus side for me is the monochrome production which adds a lot to its retro charme. 

If you just wanna go for the retro look but nevertheless a quite decent model which was up to date when produced then both are a good choice, however I'd rather recommend the Schleich Replica Brachiosaurus or the even bigger Tamiya Brachiosaurus if you like the model a bit more lifelike.

[sauroid]

if you don't mind a JP-esque but very well detailed Brachiosaurus then get the Papo.

[Joey]

Well, both are outdated but you sure are aware of that. If only to add one of these to my collection I'd personally go for the Invicta, just because I find it more elegant/majestic and not as goofy/funny looking in the face. The Invicta though has cheeks which makes it mouth look rather small. Also on the plus side for me is the monochrome production which adds a lot to its retro charme. 

If you just wanna go for the retro look but nevertheless a quite decent model which was up to date when produced then both are a good choice, however I'd rather recommend the Schleich Replica Brachiosaurus or the even bigger Tamiya Brachiosaurus if you like the model a bit more lifelike.

Invicta it is then. Thank you Lanthanotus!

[Gwangi]

The Invicta is a classic that has stood the test of time. One my my all time favorite figures. Love the Carnegie too, and I have it, but it shows its age.